Shooting Mystery is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

5 Best Scope for 17 HMR Savage Rifles [Full Buying Guide]

Best Scope for 17 HMR Savage

Developed by Hornady, the .17 HMR (Hornady Magnum Rimfire) is considered one of the most popular rimfire calibers nowadays. As the Hornady round possesses a relatively flat trajectory along with a high muzzle velocity, it’s a good choice for plinkers and varmint hunting.

Most of the time, the original sights of standard .17 HMR chambered firearms should let you utilize the advantages of the cartridge to some extent. However, if you want to optimize your shooting experience with the .17 HMR, you must use the best scopes for 17 HMR savage rifles.

There are a lot of riflescopes on the market, so which ones are the best .17 HMR scopes? Well, if you are new to rimfire rifles and don’t really know how to choose .17 HMR scopes, you’ve come to the right place.

For this article, we reviewed the specifications of some of the best rifle scopes for .17 HMR available on the market. A shopping guide for novice rimfire shooters is provided as well to help you make a logical decision.

Take a look at the information below, and you should be able to secure a great .17 HMR scope without much difficulty.

Best Value
Simmons Whitetail 4-12x40mm Rifle Scope
Simmons Whitetail Rifle Scope
Best Overall
Bushnell Banner Dusk & Dawn 4-12×40 Riflescope
Best Versatility
Nikon Prostaff P3 Predator Hunter
Nikon Prostaff P3 Predator Hunter

The Best Scope for 17 HMR Savage – Full Reviews

1. Bushnell Banner Dusk & Dawn 4-12×40 Riflescope


Bushnell Banner Dusk & Dawn Riflescope

» Best Price on OpticsPlanet «
» Check Price on Cabelas «
» Check Price on Brownells «
» Check Price on Amazon «


  • Magnification: 4 – 12x
  • Lens Diameter: 40 Millimeters
  • Dimensions: 16.2 x 2.4 x 3 Inches
  • Weight: 0.8 Pounds

Reliable and affordable, the Bushnell Banner Dusk & Dawn is regarded as the best .17 HMR scope in terms of all-around performance. Due to its fully multi-coated lenses, this scope can gather light effectively and efficiently.

From early morning to late evening, the Bushnell rifle scope can provide shooters with crisp and high-contrast target images. As the eye relief is generous, you should also be able to shoot from many positions without getting a scope eye.

For its adjustment mechanism, it’s easy to make changes to the elevation/windage setting of Bushnell Banner Dusk & Dawn. The turrets can be manipulated at a moment’s notice, and thanks to the ¼ MOA adjustment value, you can set up the Banner scope with great precision.

Given that the riflescope is fog proof, waterproof, and shockproof, it can perform well with distinction in challenging environments.

While its magnification power is not the most impressive, the scope is nonetheless an excellent choice if you need a hunting scope.

  • Quality glass
  • Can hold zero well
  • Excellent light transmission
  • Generous eye relief
  • Quality control could use some improvements
  • There are a couple of reports about dust particles

2. Simmons Whitetail Rifle Scope


Simmons Whitetail 4-12x40mm Rifle Scope



    • Magnification: 4 – 12x
    • Lens Diameter: 40 Millimeters
    • Dimensions: 14.5 x 3.3 x 3.4 Inches
    • Weight: 1.8 Pound

Calibrated for .22 LR/.17 HMR, the Simmons Whitetail is highly sought after by owners of rimfire rifles. Using time-tested manufacturing techniques and high-grade material, the Simmons scope can last for a lifetime on the field.

In addition to that, the presence of well-manufactured lenses makes sure that you could spot targets anytime and anywhere. With a maximum magnification level of 12x and a minimum magnification level of 3x, this scope should match average shooters’ needs and requirements.

Possessing fingertip adjustable turrets, the Simmons Whitetail could be zeroed in a blink of an eye. Moreover, you would be able to adjust the elevation and windage settings of the Simmons rifle scope without much difficulty.

A side focus knob is also available, which allows you to take care of the parallax adjustment and improve accuracy.

For the mounting, the scope’s lightweight tube can be attached to most rimfire rifles in circulation without affecting their balance.  All you have to do is find an appropriate set of mounting rings, and you should be good to go.

  • Tough and light
  • Ergonomic turrets
  • Reasonable price  
  • Inadequate quality control
  • Several turret malfunctions are noted  

3. Nikon Prostaff P3 Predator Hunter


Nikon Prostaff P3 Predator Hunter



  • Magnification: 4 – 12x
  • Lens Diameter: 40 Millimeters
  • Dimensions: 19.2 x 4.5 x 4 Inches
  • Weight: 1.2 Pounds

Want a versatile and flexible scope? Then you should take a look at Nikon ProStaff. Featuring a magnification range of 4 – 12x, the Nikon riflescope can please both hunters and competitive shooters alike.

To ensure the shooter’s vision and field of view is bright and clear, this scope uses fully multicoated lenses, which offer a light transmission rate of 98%.

Because of that, you could acquire your target in low light conditions without much difficulty. The scope’s quick focus eyepiece also helps you bring targets into view at a moment’s notice.

As it is O-ring-sealed and nitrogen-purged, the Nikon ProStaff is waterproof and fog proof. As a result, the Nikon scope can handle pretty much anything you throw at it.

For the reticle, the scope utilizes a BDC pattern, making it easy to aim and shoot at a long range.

By using the see-through circles of the scope reticle, you can consistently hit your targets in long-range shooting. Since the scope employs spring-loaded zero rest turrets, it’s simple for you to make adjustments on the field too.

  • Well-made and rugged
  • Straightforward operation
  • High endurance/resistance
  • The crosshair is a bit thick
  • Some customers receive used products   

4. Burris Fullfield II 4.5-14×42

» Best Price on OpticsPlanet «
» Check Price on Brownells «
» Check Price on Amazon «


  • Magnification: 4.5 – 14x
  • Lens Diameter: 35 Millimeters
  • Dimensions: 12 x 2.8 x 3 Inches
  • Weight: 0.75 Pound

For people in need of a short-to-mid range scope, the Burris Fullfield II is one of the most popular options available on the market. Since the Burris rifle scope is compact and light, you can mount it on rimfire rifles without experiencing any balance issues.

For the glass of the lens, the scope incorporates multicoated, anti-glare lenses, which permit it to operate in less than ideal situations. Made from high-quality material, the riflescope can handle a lot of abuse and remains operational.

To adjust the setting of the Burris Fullfield II, you could use a coin or a bullet to manipulate the turrets. That being said, you should be to make changes using your hands if you desire.

Overall, the Burris scope’s adjustment mechanism requires some time to get used to, but it’s quite dependable.

Furthermore, experienced shooters and experts appreciate the turret’s ability to hold zero when exposed to recoils and vibration. Each click equals a value ½ MOA which is sufficient in most cases.

  • Lightweight tube
  • Crystal clear lenses
  • Generous eye relief
  • The turrets are not exactly user-friendly
  • Inconsistent performance between products  

5. Vortex Optics Crossfire II 2-7×32

» Best Price on OpticsPlanet «
» Check Price on Cabelas «
» Check Price on Brownells «
» Check Price on Amazon «


  • Magnification: 2 – 7x
  • Lens Diameter: 32 Millimeters
  • Dimensions: 14 x 3 x 3 Inches
  • Weight: 0.85 Pounds

Designed to assist shooters with holdover estimating, the Vortex Optics Crossfire II is the best .17 HMR scope when you regularly have to shoot between a short, medium, and long range.

Featuring a long eye relief and a wide field of view, the Vortex Optics Crossfire II lets you acquire targets in the shortest amount of time possible.

As the scope utilizes aircraft-grade aluminum for its tube, it can handle recoil, vibration, and impact without suffering damages.

The Vortex Crossfire selects the famous Dead-Hold BDC pattern for the reticle, which lets you make precise compensation.

You can figure out the approximate holdover and windage corrections you need to take through the hash marks of the scope reticle.

Once you finish calculating, the only thing left to do is adjust the Vortex Optics scope’s turrets as the situation requires. The scope adjustment turrets are capped and finger adjusted, so you should be able to make necessary changes at your leisure.

  • Affordable
  • Solid body
  • Great warranty
  • There are reports about durability issues
  • Reduced eye relief at high power settings

Choosing the Best Scope for Your .17 HMR Savage: Tips and Tricks for Novices

Scope Strength

At all times, remember that you have to take care of your scope and keep it out of harm’s way. That being said, you should make sure that your scope can handle a couple of hits without bending/breaking apart.

For hunters in need of a rimfire scope, strength is among the most important criterion. While hunting, the scope will be exposed to vibrations as well as sudden impacts.

A fragile product would not last long in such situations. In usual cases, high-grade aluminum should be an ideal material choice if you want a tough scope.

Environmental Resistance

In the outdoors, numerous elements can degrade the performance of your scope, which is why you have to think about environmental resistance. Most of the time, you should go for riflescopes with nitrogen/argon purging gases and O-rings.

The presence of these features indicates that the rifle scopes are both fog proof and waterproof.

On top of that, a riflescope that possesses hard anodized coatings would have improved corrosion and wear & tear resistance.

Magnification Power

Of course, the .17 HMR is not as strong as centerfire cartridges, but that doesn’t mean you have to keep the scope magnification power low. In fact, as the Hornady round could reach out to a long range, the maximum magnification range of your scope should be at least 9x.

For competitive shooting, there is a wide variety of high-power scopes money can buy. All you have to do is select a model that matches your shooting distance.

Variable power scopes offer shooters a lot of flexibility and versatility, but fixed power scopes have their charms as well.

Variable power scopes are great for those who want to switch between shooting a short, medium, and long range. However, a fixed power scope that can work for long-range shooting is also not a bad idea if you want to strictly practice shooting targets as far as you can.

Inspecting the Lenses

It goes without saying that the quality of the lenses greatly influences the scope’s performance. If the lenses are bad, the scope is good for nothing, so you have to be careful and thorough for this factor.

Generally speaking, it’s a good idea for you to go after multicoated lenses because their light transmission rate and anti-glare capabilities are excellent.

With multicoated lenses, you can acquire bright and sharp target images in low-light conditions.

In many cases, it is also worth the time and effort to ensure the lenses can withstand abrasion elements.

Look Over the Adjustment Turrets

No matter what kind of shooting purpose the scope is used for, having well-designed adjustment turrets is a must. If you cannot make accurate windage and elevation changes, you would not be able to shoot with precision.

To competitive shooters, high-profile exposed turrets should perform well as the design lets people make adjustments with relative ease.

On the other hand, hunters need to stick with low-profile capped turrets to prevent the settings from changing accidentally while passing through dense bushes. Pay special attention to the adjustment value per click as well if you want to land your shots on targets consistently.

Duplex, Mildot, and BDC: Which Reticle Style Is Best?

Many people like to use a duplex reticle because it’s simple to use and works well from dusk to dawn. Considered to be a standard choice, the duplex reticle will not disappoint when it comes to hunting in the woods.

For people who need a way to determine the target range, a mildot reticle is an excellent option thanks to its evenly spaced milliradian dots. By using the dots, you can estimate the approximate distance between you and your targets.

In the case you want something to help you locate the point of aim in long-range shooting, the BDC reticle is surely your best bet. However, it could take quite a bit of time for you to get used to the BDC reticle and its layout.

Reputable Brands You Should Keep in Mind

Technically, you can get your rifle scope from any brand on the market as long as you are certain that it suits your needs and requirements.

Nonetheless, you should prioritize products that come from famous brands in the industry if possible. Well-known manufacturers don’t just suddenly become popular. It takes a lot of effort to attract and satisfy customers.

That is why if a brand can remain in business for a long time, it must have done something right. Sure, products and services from reputable brands are not perfect, but their performance should be better than lesser-known brands.

Here are a couple of scope brands you have to keep an eye out for while checking out available options:

  • Nikon
  • Leupold
  • Vortex Optics
  • Bushnell
  • BSA
  • Barska
  • Burris
  • Hawke
  • Simmons

If you come across scopes from these brands, rest assured that it’s worth the time to take a look at them.

In fact, we mention several of these brands in our Guide on the Top Rifle Scopes under 500 Dollars if you’re interested in some budget options.



April 13, 2022 - Made minor updates to content
March 24, 2022 - Added 1 new artice link
October 4, 2021 - Added new product link options
September 20, 2021 - Reviewed and updated article links, updated article title, updated product links, marked 2 products as discontinued/unavailable

About the author